21 best turtleneck sweaters for women and men | CNN Underscored

When you think of necessary closet basics, you can’t forget about one very important cold weather essential: turtleneck sweaters. Stylists agree that the best turtlenecks will become one of your most-worn fall fashion styles because they provide warmth, are extremely versatile and suit every body type. “Turtlenecks also serve as a built-in scarf, making them the perfect accessory for those who are perpetually losing their scarves,” says celebrity fashion stylist Eric Owes.

In all seriousness, Owes says that turtlenecks are a “must-have staple” in everyone’s wardrobe for the way they instantly pull an outfit together and help you look effortlessly polished. All turtlenecks aren’t created equal, though. Keep reading to learn what separates an okay turtleneck from a top-quality design and discover 21 dependable styles for men and women.

Related article These are the jackets our editors are dusting off for fall and winter

“I own multiple colors of this affordable turtleneck,” says professional stylist Jamie Grimstad Huth. Made from 100% merino wool, this simple yet elegant sweater has a subtle sheen and will keep you warm on chilly days. Plus, compared to other wool sweaters that are finicky to care for, this one can be thrown in the wash.

This is another option that Grimstad Huth owns in more than one color, and she says this turtleneck is extremely versatile. She’s been known to layer it under a blazer for a professional look or throw it on with leggings to go to the gym. Everlane’s Supima cotton is known for its supreme softness and stretch, allowing it to beautifully conform to your body and keep you extra cozy.

Figure-hugging turtlenecks are ideal for layering as well as for nights out when you want to keep things simple yet make a statement. New York-based professional stylist Xie Antonio recommends this pick from intimates brand Intimissimi due to the fact that it’s lightweight, made of cashmere (which means it’s ultra soft!) and the lower price point. Antonio is such a big fan that she owns it in multiple colors.

Underscored’s fashion editor Sophie Shaw breaks out this warm option every fall and winter. It’s made with Uniqlo’s HeatTech material, which means it acts as a thermal base layer without adding bulk. In fact, it’s the perfect weight for layering. Shaw also notes that the high-neck silhouette works especially well for people like her, who have a shorter neck that can be overpowered by the extra material that comes with a traditional turtleneck.

Related article The 28 best fall sweaters under $50, according to fashion stylists

Contrary to popular belief, turtlenecks don’t just need to be reserved for the cooler months. Sleeveless options, like this Grimstad Huth-recommended pick, can be worn year round. “On a cooler summer night, this is great with a pair of jeans or bermuda shorts for a chic look,” she says. “In colder months, it can offer a bit more breathability and be a great layering piece.”

Smart, subtle elements like its padded shoulders, merino wool/cashmere blend and rib knit trim instantly elevate this turtleneck. Grimstad Huth says it makes for a great layering piece — she recommends wearing it underneath a blazer — or statement piece: “Pair it with a great pair of jeans or a miniskirt.”

You’re going to have to splurge a little to get a quality cashmere turtleneck, and if you’re able, Grimstad Huth suggests going with this pick. “Jenni Kayne is known for her knitwear,” she says. “This cozy silhouette is high-quality and offers a versatile style for day-to-night dressing. It’s the perfect wardrobe staple.”

Amazon fashion should not be slept on — especially the sweaters. This fan-favorite pick will keep the cozy vibes alive all through the cold weather seasons with its soft woven texture that will make you feel like you’re wrapped in a blanket. Choose from 27 hues ranging from neutrals like black and brown to more vibrant options like a bright pink or deep green.

Grimstad Huth has been a major fan of cropped turtleneck styles that feature tighter waistbands, like this pick from Banana Republic. “I find that these offer more versatility when styling. For example, it could be styled with a pair of high-waisted jeans or with a high-waisted midi skirt for a more tailored look.”

Sure, form-fitting styles look sleek, but if you’re after a turtleneck that will stay completely snug against your body throughout busy days, opt for this turtleneck bodysuit. Made with a combination of cotton and cashmere, the ribbed garment boasts a feathery softness that layers wonderfully under blazers, leather jackets or vests. The high-cut leg openings and thong cut ensures no lines are visible when worn with jeans or silk slip skirts.

Sleeveless sweaters are having a moment this year for their streamlined appearance that makes layering so much easier (no more trying to force bulky sleeves to fit in your jacket!). This turtleneck design from Steve Madden also elongates your torso, thanks to the expertly placed vertical ribbing.

Related article 5 fall fashion trends to shop on Amazon from $9, according to style experts

Uniqlo is one of those rare brands that excels at crafting clothing for both men and women. Grimstad Huth can’t get enough of its offerings and constantly recommends it to clients of all genders. “Uniqlo just does affordable turtlenecks so well,” she says. “These are great layering pieces for men but can also be styled on their own with a pair of jeans.”

“Naked Cashmere’s recent change in management has completely elevated the brand,” Grimstad Huth says. “Its knit pieces, including this turtleneck, are great if you want a more affordable price point without compromising quality.”

A quick way to look sharp, according to Antonio, is by wearing this 100% merino wool turtleneck with a field jacket, bomber or trench coat. This style has over 10 colors to choose from, and while many of them lean neutral, don’t be afraid to go for red to add a vibrant pop to your cold weather wardrobe.

While many cashmere pieces will set you back hundreds, Quince keeps prices low by cutting out the middleman. Antonio recommends the brand, and especially this cashmere turtleneck, if you’re after high-quality material without the high price point. “It will last you decades,” she says.

A form-fitting turtleneck is a necessity in every man’s wardrobe due to its versatility alone. Wearing this with jeans will help you look instantly polished, and it really makes you appear more dignified when paired with a suit. Grimstad Huth adores the quality of this merino wool piece for the price.

“If you’re looking — or are able — to spend a little more, look no further than Boglioli for all of your wardrobe staples,” says Grimstad Huth. While the brand may be known for their suits, she says that their turtlenecks, like this one, fly relatively under the radar yet offer supreme comfort and quality that will last in your closet for decades.

Related article Men’s fall fashion essentials: A head-to-toe guide

Cable-knit designs are an easy way to dress up your outfit for special occasions, après-ski parties and other cold weather get-togethers. Antonio loves this classic design from Ralph Lauren that has a relaxed fit and feels supremely soft, thanks to a mix of wool and cashmere.

For a contemporary clean-cut turtleneck, turn to Gutteridge. The Italian heritage brand has been perfecting their garment making for over 140 years. When it comes to this specific design, they use the finest merino wool for a silky-soft touch that feels smooth and comfortable against your body — no overheating here.

For those who like the idea of a turtleneck but aren’t fully committed to the feeling of the fabric on their neck, this sweater gives you the option to zip the neck up as high or low as you want. Not only does this allow you to find a fit that’s most comfortable for you but it offers plenty of versatility and layering possibilities.

Mock necks look extremely similar to turtlenecks; the main difference is there’s not extra fabric for you to fold down. If you’re not too keen on the additional fabric but still like the look of a high neck, this comfortable shirt is a solid middle ground. The lightweight terry construction offers a touch of warmth yet is still breathable and wicks away excess moisture.

All our experts agree that you should take the fit, fabric and neck style into account when selecting a turtleneck. Of the three, fit may be the most important. Grimstad Huth recommends choosing a fit that complements your body type or pairs well with the other elements of your outfit. “Slim fits are great for layering, while relaxed fits offer a casual, cozy and more relaxed look,” she says.

When it comes to the fabric, opt for natural fibers like wool, cashmere or cotton. “Natural fabrics are breathable. They allow you to feel warm without being sweaty,” Antonio says. The three materials mentioned offer different levels of warmth, softness and breathability. Because of this, Grimstad Huth suggests owning one of each as they “all serve different functions.”

Finally, consider the neck style. Grimstad Huth says the most common turtleneck styles are classic, mock neck and funnel. “Choose a neck style based on your comfort, the weather and your style preferences,” she says.

There’s no right or wrong way to wear your turtleneck. It all comes down to personal preference. However, Grimstad Huth says wearing the neck up “provides more warmth and a sleek look,” while flipping it down can “create a more casual and approachable style.” Assess the fabric and shape of the overall top and then see what looks best and feels the most comfortable to you. Owes adds that “as long as you’re confidently rocking that turtleneck, it doesn’t matter which way the neck is facing. Just own it and make your own fashion statement!”

There are two aspects to the fit of a turtleneck that you should pay attention to: how it fits around your neck and as how it fits around your body. When it comes to the neck, Grimstad Huth says it should feel snug without being too tight. The body fit differs depending on whether you’re looking for a layering piece or a sweater. “It can vary from slim to relaxed, depending on your preference and intended look,” she says. “Ensure that the shoulders align with your shoulder seams, and the length is either cropped or long enough to tuck into the bottoms you’re pairing with.”

This depends on the look you’re after and how you want it to fit. If you prefer something that skims your body, opt for your normal size. That said, oversized looks are also big right now, and if you’re after that, you can size up.

Read our review